Archive for the 'Reviews' Category

Doyle is back as Reading sink Rams

Reading 1 (Doyle 63) Derby County 0

We got Row B seats in the East Stand for this game and my son really enjoyed being so close to the action and also in amongst the louder section of fans. However, being so close to the pitch made it much harder to follow patterns of play in the game, and indeed the way Duberry often punted the ball high into the air, I spent much of the game looking up.

The game started with most of the play at the away end. Reading had three clear chances, 2 for Hunt and 1 for Doyle before Murty hit a shot that clearly was handball for a penalty (on the replays in MOTD2 anyway; couldn’t tell where I was sitting). It wasn’t pretty but at least Derby never looked like scoring which was a bit improvement over last week.

Second half and it was still mostly Reading, but they weren’t getting very far. The number of freekicks messed up by Shorey and Rosenior reached double figures, and eventually Rosenior was replaced by Jonny Oster. Whilst Oster himself didn’t change the game with any individual piece of skill, this was the turning point in the game. I think it was the fact we had a proper right midfielder on the pitch.

Harper took the ball right from a throw in, passing to Murty. Murty came forward, whilst Oster took the left back wide, Murty was able to find space to put in a cross. The ball came across the Derby defence (taking a deflection I think) and finding the head of Kevin Doyle. Doyle guided the ball to the far post, and after taking an seeming eternity, the ball beat the keeper and was in the net.

I was hoping Doyle would come our way, but instead he enjoyed a celebration with Kingsley. Good man.

Kingsley celebration

Derby pushed forward after going 1-0 down but never troubled us really, getting caught offside more than once or twice. It was Reading that came closer to getting a 2nd as Oster had about half an hour to take a shot from about 7 yards out, but took a whole hour and was closed out.

Special mentions to
1) Dave Kitson. Tireless running and good all round forward play. My MOTD.
2) The bloke next to me for going on and on about how bad Dubbery and Gunnardson(sic) were. Whilst he had a point about Gunnarson, you should not barrack the players, do you want them to lose ?
3) Derby leftback, . Manages to handball twice (once for what should have been a pen) and boots the ball hard straight at John Oster and still doesn’t get booked.
4) My son for repeating a joke endlessly now doubt annoying everyone around us “Look there is Kingsley, lioning down”

You might also want to read :

7-4

Portsmouth 7 Reading 4.

How can you analyse a game like that? I’d run out space just listing the goal scorers. Instead I’ll detail the small bits and how I listened to the game.

I’d been helping out in the garden at my children’s school until around 3 when one of the teachers went to leave in the card. She is a ST holder and lives very close to the ground. She reported that we’d just conceeded. By the time I got home it was 2-0 and the BBC Berkshire commentary recorded how we were being totally overrun, picking out Murty and Gunnarsson as the major problems. I then heard we got one back, but no one was sure who had got it - if Rosenior’s shot had crossed the line it was his, otherwise Hunt had got the followup (it was Rosenior’s goal)

Second half and I was still listening to BBC Berkshire. 2-2 through a howler from David James, 3-2 to Portmouth, then a penalty. Astonishing game. Shorey missed it and then it all went completely and utterly wrong. I think I stopped listening at about 5-2. I mean, how can you lose track of the number of goals scored in a game.

I put the telly and watched the equivalent of people reading out teletext for you, Sky Sport’s Soccer Saturday. Chris Kamara was going mental reporting on the game. Every so often, they report “There’s been another goal at Fratten Park!” and I’d think, we’ll 5-3 or 6-4 wouldn’t be so bad, but the goals kept coming. In the end 7-4, the highest aggregate Premiership game ever.

Later on I watched Match of the Day, and we were on first. How I wished we were the last game like usual.

You can’t analyse that except to say that whatever the question is, Gunarsson is not the answer.

You might also want to read :
  • No related posts

Torrez smashes Reading out of Cup

Liverpool beat Reading 4-2 with a hat-trick from Fernando Torrez to dump the Royals out of the cup in the 3rd round for the second season running.

I didn’t go to the game tonight for a number of reasons. Cost of an extra game in a busy month, too late to take my son and the fact that getting to the ground would have been a nightmare. Once again there were reports of a nightmare on the buses with traffic chaos on the motorway near the ground. The buses were running on the same timetable as the Chelsea game and I got to the ground at 8:05 for that and this was a 7:45 kickoff. I watched on telly and noticed how many empty seats at the start were only filled by half time. No drummer until about 15 minutes into the game, so it must have been bad!

Anyway, to the match itself and it was clear that Torrez was a class above every other player on the pitch. Not surprising considering he cost about 5 times the whole cost of the Reading side. He ended up with a hat trick and could have had a few more. Duberry and Bikey actually had good games and did well but the Spaniard was simply too good for them. What was surprising was why Benitez rested him for the recent league games and played him tonight. Is the Carling Cup more important that the Premier League?

Coppell rested a lot of the Reading 1st team and drafted in quite a few of the fringe players. Of the additions, Lita started slowly but got better as the game went on and ran the Liverpool defence ragged. He also produced the best piece of skill on the night, a fabulous overhead kick that the keeper did well to tip over the bar.

Convey had another good game, scoring a cracking goal (even if Lita was offside for it) and is generally getting back to his form of two seasons ago. Its now debatable whether Hunt should keep his place with the improving Convey coming back to form. If only the right midfield position had similar selection problems.

John Halls, despite scoring and putting in a few good crosses, looked way out of his depth. Clearly not at the same level as the rest of the players on the pitch, he was slow and was out of position quite often and was lucky not to get more than just one yellow card for pulling players back who had gone passed him. He was replaced by the young James Henry who showed promise for an 18 year old during the brief spell he was on.

Those that did less well also included Shane Long and Fae. Long looked off the pace and lacked a good first touch all night. Fae is still feeling his way into English football and whilst had a number of good moments lacked a real purpose going forward and doesn’t seem to be able to tackle well, an important skill for a central midfielder.

However, Reading mostly matched Liverpool player for player except for Torrez who looks like he is going to have a good season and if Benitez plays him often enough, Liverpool might just win the league.

You might also want to read :
  • No related posts

Last minute winner for lucky Reading

Just got back from the game and have to contribute the 2-1 win against Wigan to a combination of pure luck and an astute substitution from Coppell. ` First half and Reading were playing well, on top and creating chances. Should have been 3-0 up before it finally became 1-0. Kirkland spilled a shot from Doyle and Dave Kitson was on hand to poke the ball in the net.

2nd half (and I’ve seen this a number of times now at the Madjeski) Reading were a different team, poor, 2nd to the ball, passing going wrong and conceded a goal from a corner.

Bobby Convey replaced Liam Rosenior and turned the game round. He found space, and ran at the Wigan defence, turned them and generally turned the game back in Reading’s favour.

But, before Reading scored we had a real scare at the other end, Marcus Hahnemann was left exposed on a 1 on 1 with Wigan’s Aghahowa and clipped the forward as he went passed. To the striker’s eternal credit, he didn’t go down as he thought he had a clear open goal to score, but he was slowed enough to let the defence back in.

But Reading had enough to score in the very last minute to gain a much needed three points. Kitson played a brilliant reverse pass to play in Harps to score. The crowd went mad. There was even time for a last minute shoving match but the crowd went home very happy with the result, but still concerned by the performance of some of the players.

You might also want to read :

Sunderland 2 Reading 1

Things didn’t get any better for Reading away to Sunderland. Despite avoiding a third 3-0 defeat in a row, Reading never looked like winning this game. Dave Kitson scored what was a consolation goal towards the end of the game that Reading lost effectively in the 1st minute of the second half when they went 2-0 down.

Reading are now third from bottom and despite cries of “Second Season Syndrome” I trust Steve Coppell to turn things around. Fates have conspired against me (or perhaps for me and I’ve only seen Reading place well so far this season; United away on telly (hard fought 0-0, Chelsea at home (won the first half; no disgrace to lose to the Billionaires) and Everton at home (1-0 win and played generally well against a team that still looking good).

The defeats have come away from home and at home to West Ham who are now 6th (I was thankfully unable to see that game). Having not seen in full any of the last three games it is hard for me to know exactly what is wrong. Is it the defence missing the hopefully soon to return Sonko (perhaps Ingarmarsson has lost form)? Or have Reading not replaced Sidwell properly (the new signing not found their feet or form)? Or the loss of all three right sided midfielders to a team based on wide play?

Likely it is a combination of all three, but you look at the results and sort of can see that you would not expect Reading to win them. Although Bolton are bottom three too, last season they were top 6. Sunderland are a new team and running well at home (beating Spurs). West Ham are refurbished and back to their form of two seasons ago. Yet the Reading of last season would have picked up at least 2 or 3 points from those games whatever the opposition.

This Saturday is Wigan at home and whilst at this stage of the season not game is a “must win”; we should win it. If not, I’ll see first hand why not.

My son has a chart where he can put all the scores down. Filling it in hasn’t been too much fun so far. Let’s hope it gets better soon.

You might also want to read :

Reading 0-3 West Ham

Ouch. Reading got ripped apart on the counter attack by a very fast paced West Ham team. The early goal set the pace and meant that Reading had to attack. As a result, West Ham were able to pick us off time after time.

On the one hand the scoreline slightly flattered West Ham, as Hunt hit the bar when it was only 1-0 and at 2-0 down, Doyle had a penalty saved and West Ham’s final goal came in the 94th minute when Reading had most of their defence up front desperately trying to get one back.

On the other hand, West Ham had enough one on ones with Hahnemann to make a reverse of last season 6-0 win possible. Hahnemann made a couple of key saves but maybe the most important chance in the 6th minute was one he should have saved and didn’t.

Coppell was good in the post match interviews, and I fully expect him to sort it out and turn it round. We clearly missed a proper right sided midfielder and hopefully either Little or Oster will be back soon. Duberry was far too slow to this sort of game, and the quicker Sonko gets back the better. Finally new signing Rosenior is reportedly a very fast player and has also played at right midfield, so maybe he can fill in there and play right back against the faster sides.

You might also want to read :

Reading 1 Everton 0

Reading got their first win of the season at a drizzle drenched Madjeski Stadium against the table-topping Everton. Stephen Hunt scored a well deserved goal and Andy Johnson was denied by a post late on to give the win to Reading.

We were planning on getting the bus but actually met up with some East Stand season ticket holders who gave my son and I a lift to the ground. So in fact we got their incredibly early to make up for Wednesday’s game against Chelsea. So early that we wandered around wondering what to do with ourselves. A couple of pints and a coke was the answer (again to make up for the Chelsea game). However, I paid the price ten minutes into the game because my son needed the toilet! Better than 2 minutes before half time I suppose in this case.

The game started with Reading playing particularly well. Gunnarsson was back in for the suspended Cisse. Seol had replaced Oster and Bikey was starting for the injured Duberry. Bikey certainly took his chance as he was incredible, making the job of marking Andy Johnson look easy. All the defence played well, but poor Graham Murty went down with another injury after 20 minutes and was replaced with De La Cruz.

Just has we were thinking that all the hard work in the first half was coming to nothing, up popped Stephen Hunt, taking hold of a De La Cruz long throw that the Everton defence failed to handle and deftly stuck the ball into the net past the Everton keeper Howard. Perfect time to score a goal at 43 minutes.

Everton played better second half, and Reading couldn’t quite keep up the pace. Doyle and Long were playing well up front, but looked increasingly tired and the Seol (who had a good game as well) got a back injury and was replaced by Oster. Then came the moment that two American blokes at the front of the South Stand had been waiting for. Hunt picked up a thigh strain after providing again a tireless effort of running and skill and had to be replaced. On came Bobby Convey to a standing ovation and the two American guys got their USA flag out. It is great to see both the American support and Bobby’s return.

However, it looked like Reading were going to run out of players as substitute Oster went down with an injury as well. We were going to finish the game with ten men again (no sending off for a change) but Oster came back on to hobble around up front and Kevin Doyle finished the game on the right midfield.

Near the death, Everton came closest to scoring with McFaddon (rightly booked for diving) putting in a cross that fooled Hahnemann and hit the bar. The ball fell to the previously quiet Johnson but he fluffed he shot and hit De La Cruz on the hand, then fell to him again. He shot again and hit the post. What a let off. Johnson always scores against Reading and should have again. Not this time. The Reading fans were ecstatic after getting the first win of the season.

4 points from the first three game and 4 more points than from the same fixtures as last season. In the car on the way hope everyone was full of optimism for the coming season.

You might also want to read :

Reading 1 Chelsea 2

What a good game; and failing to avoid the well known cliche it was certainly a game of two halves. Reading were excellent in the first half, and poor in the second. Chelsea were woeful in the first half and good enough in the second.

Where to start? Well, not the beginning, because I missed the kick-off. As the game kicked off I was running from the bus to the turnstile (and getting my foot soaked as I stepped in a huge puddle). There were reports of all sorts of trouble with the buses (the Henley bus broke down) and ours was 15 minutes late getting to us. We then got caught up in the usual traffic jams through town and around the ground as an almighty rain storm dented holes in the roof. Once I finally got to my seat, the game was already in full flow and I’d missed all the pre-match stuff including Kingsley and the PA team. (As I also missed my pre-game pint I queued up for one at halftime and missed all the half time stuff from the boys as well. Sorry guys, hopefully the bus will get us to the ground earlier on Saturday).

Chelsea had the first real chance when Drogba hit the post, but he was actually offside. After that the first half was all Reading. If only we’d put away the chances we were given. Hunt was excellent and despite my nervousness was man of the match, didn’t put a foot round and made the Chelsea defenders look fools with his neat flicks. Duberry was having a good game, Murty and Oster we combining well on the right and Doyle and Long were working the defence well (however they are a bit similar to play together). Harper and new boy Cisse were doing well in the middle against Lampard and Sidwell. Lampard was invisible, and Sidwell was running round looking like he had a point to prove, but ended up just fouling a lot (in the end he got booked). Unfortunately, his Reading replacement was doing just the same and got booked as well for a lunge.

The Reading goal came just after a substitution. Duberry pulled up with a groin strain and Reading brought Bikey on. His first job was to run up as Reading had a free-kick. The ball was sent to the edge of the area and Ingermarrson sent the ball towards the goal and Kevin Doyle. Amazingly, Cech came to collect the ball, and only suceeded in taking out Doyle and his markers. The ball went untouched across the 6 yard box to fall at an amazed Bikey’s feet, who planted the ball in the net from his first touch of the game.

The crowd went wild and for the rest of the half it was party atmosphere (”Sidwell, Sidwell, what’s the score?”) The Chelsea fans were pretty poor. Noisy at the start, but repetitive. As soon as they were behind, they shut up. Sadly, Reading failed to make it 2 or 3-0 when they had the changes. Someone blased over the ball, Doyle shot a couple tamely and worst of all Oster hit the post from about 6 yards away.

The 2nd half started and Mourhino took a gamble with making all his substitutions and it paid off. Sidwell was replaced and it allowed Lampard to get further forward. Whilst Reading were trying to sort this out, Chelsea scored. Lampard was left unmarking in midfield by Cisse and drove through to score. Poor defending, and perhaps the goalkeeper should have saved it.

2 minutes later it was 2-1 and there was nothing Marcus could have done with the 2nd. Drogba hit and excellent curling powerful strike from 30 yards (exactly as the bloke in the line for the beer at half time told me he would do!).

The Chelsea fans woke up (”Sidwell, Sidwell, what’s the score?” Doesn’t actually work if he isn’t playing) to which Reading replied with “You only sing when your winning”. What I truly hated was all the suits in the West Stand coming out of their little boxes cheering. 1) Get in the away end 2) if you are in the wrong end, be subtle 3) don’t watch the game on tv when you are at the ground. One fat suited git got pelted by something and when complained to a steward was told to shut up. Good work from the stewards. And he really annoyed a St. Johns Ambulance person. Would probably have been chucked out if he wasn’t in a box!

After the goals, Chelsea mostly sat back on their lead with breaks from Malouda (looked sharp) and Wright-Philips (fast but ineffective). Reading had no answer and whilst they made a few chances, they’d run out of steam. It got worse when Cisse was sent off for a 2nd booking. Pizzaro went down in similar fashion to Evra, but unlike Kitson, Cisse had mearly clipped him. I think that is the only way Pizzaro fits in at Chelsea. On what I’ve seen so far, he doesn’t look Premiership class, let alone Chelsea class (not that they have class, but you understand what I mean).

Oster, Long and Doyle faded from the game in the second half and we really needed our injuried/suspended players back. Little, Lita and Kitson could have turned the game back to us, and it shows how small our squad is compared to Chelsea who managed to turn the game with their substitutions despite having a number of players out injured.

Ashley Cole got booked late on for the worst piece of time wasting I’ve ever seen. He effectively walked away from the pitch with the ball in his hands. If the ref had let him, he’d have gone down the tunnel with in. Then he kicked it away.

It ended 2-1 to Chelsea and Hunt and Cech hugged (apparently; I rushed off to the bus dead on final whistle as no doubt it would leave on time even if it had been late arriving) and Reading fans were left wondering how close we’d got again. What might have been. Chelsea will be relying on Drogba a lot this season, even more than Terry and Cech as he is the player they have got to turn draws into wins.

You might also want to read :

Man United held by the Royals

It was a fantastic result, a great defensive performance and had some tactical genius from “Sir” Steve Coppell.

With De La Cruz and Murty in the line-up, I was wondering what sort of formation Reading were going to line up with. Normally, when Reading go 4-5-1 (a rare event usually only occurring when playing United or another big team) it is Gunnarsson who comes in at the expense of the second striker. But Gunnarsson is starting the season as first choice replacement for Sidwell, so De La Cruz came into the side.

What happened was that Murty man-marked Giggs, Shorey went on Ronaldo and Duberry on Rooney. This was real man to man marking and very hard to do. Often Murty and Shorey were next to each other as they followed their men all over the place. Duberry often ended up in midfield as Rooney dropped deep to collect the ball. Most of the time, United were unable to create any great chances. Their best chance in the first half came when Ronaldo got away from Shorey, was left 1-1 against Hunt. Hunt was left for dead by some great skill and Ronaldo floated the ball to the far post. Giggs took a shot and hit the outside of the post.

One chance Rooney had ended his game. As the ball came in from wide, Rooney rose to meet the ball, Duberry as usual in close attendance. When both players came down, Duberry landed on Rooney’s foot and it turned out to be broken. Rooney limped off, and was replaced by Nani in the second half.

United had even more possession in the second half, but seemed less potent without Rooney as they had no real striker. However, Reading just couldn’t clear the ball properly as Ferdinand and Vidic kept a close eye on Kevin Doyle. It got worse when Doyle was replaced by Kitson. 37 seconds after coming on, Dave closed down Evra from a throw and mistimed his tackle, catching Evra with studs on the leg. The ref ran over as fast as his little legs could carry him and brandished the red card. It was really harsh on the forward but the tackle did look nasty. However, most people agreed it should have been yellow. In fact, I noticed that Rooney did a similar challenge on De La Cruz in the first half which was a simple foul (ok, it wasn’t such full on contact as Kitson’s but was a similar thing and the difference was in the timing not the intent).

In the end, Reading held on to get a well deserved point. I should also point out that the travelling Reading fans out sung 70-odd thousand Man United fans. I can’t wait for Wednesday night, with a home crowd in full voice and the visit of Chelsea, sure to be interesting with Jose Mourinho and Steven Hunt involved.

You might also want to read :

Blackburn 3 Reading 3

Reading showed great fighting spirit and came back three times from behind, but ultimately fell short of a win that would have given them a European place. However, the UEFA cup spot was lost at home to Watford last week and this was a great result.

Goals came from Seol, Doyle and a great strike from Gunnarsson. With Sidwell now having left the club Reading will be on the lookup for a replacement, but Gunnarsson should be given a good long chance in the team. Each time he has played he has done well.

You might also want to read :